• Sectors we work in banner(2)

    Quick Reads

When is a charity not a charity? The High Court considers issue of mis-described charities in wills

In the recent decision of Knipe v British Racing Drivers’ Motor Sports Charity (full case reference: [2020] EWHC 3295 (Ch)) the High Court was asked to make declarations in relation to the proper construction of clauses in a will that left legacies to two charitable organisations that did not exist. The Court’s approach to interpretation provides a valuable insight into the basis upon which additional evidence can be taken into account in certain circumstances and how such ambiguous charitable legacies may be construed.

The will made reference to firstly the "British Racing Drivers' Club Benevolent Fund” and secondly the “Cancer Research Fund”. The claimant, the executor of the will and trustee of the estate, was unable to proceed with the administration of the estate as a result of the issue with the ineffective charitable names and so bought a claim under CPR Part 8. He sought relief under CPR rule 6.24 for declarations of the proper construction of both clauses.

The Court held that the first clause was to be construed in such a way that the words in the will should be read in the context in which the deceased used them. The Court found that the legacy was most likely intended for the British Racing Drivers’ Motor Sport Charity, a valid charitable organisation. The deceased had a long-standing affiliation with the organisation, having been a professional driver in his lifetime and the Court deemed it unlikely that he had any other institution in his mind when drafting his will. In relation to the second clause, which referenced the Cancer Research Fund, the Court took a slightly different approach. The claimant submitted that the clause constituted a gift for a charitable purpose and the Court, upon taking into account extrinsic evidence, agreed. As the meaning of the words “Cancer Research Fund” is ambiguous, evidence was allowed to be admitted to assist the Court with its interpretation. The Charity Commission website showed that four subsidiary charities with names affiliated with “Cancer Research Fund” existed at the time the deceased drafted his will but had since ceased to exist. Subsequently it was determined that the legacy was to be applied for the general charitable purpose of cancer research as it was considered unlikely that the deceased had a particular charity in mind at the time of making his will.  

It appears that the court is likely to construe future legacies to mis-described charities in such a way as to ensure the deceased’s wishes are complied with as accurately as possible.  However, will drafters should pay careful attention to charitable legacies to ensure that they are worded to cater for the amalgamation and/ or closure of the intended charity and the specific charity registration number should be included if possible to avoid any doubt. The inclusion of a substitute charity or caveat stipulating that the legacy is to be used for general charitable purposes can help to ensure that the administration of the estate can proceed smoothly without any need for court involvement. Of course, if a testator has drafted their will themselves the issue of mis-described charities may well be unavoidable and their relationship, if any, to certain charities may well need to be considered.  

A recent High Court decision illustrates how gifts in a will to misdescribed charities should be interpreted.

Our thinking

  • Dominic Lawrance and Catrin Harrison write for Tax Journal on the implications of the Court of Appeal judgment in the case of ‘A Taxpayer v HMRC’

    Dominic Lawrance

    In the Press

  • BBC Radio 5 Live and The Telegraph interview Sarah Jane Boon on Labour’s plans for cohabitation reform

    Sarah Jane Boon

    In the Press

  • Something Changed – Landlord recovers possession of iconic music venue

    Samuel Lear

    Quick Reads

  • When is 20% not 20%? The real impact of the proposed changes to business property relief on trading companies

    Sarah Wray

    Quick Reads

  • Relocating to Switzerland: trusts

    Alexia Egger Castillo

    Insights

  • Charles Russell Speechlys finds that Gen Z prioritises financial planning and saving amidst growing economic challenges

    Sally Ashford

    News

  • "I have finished the court case and I have decided that now is not the right time for you to see your Mum" - Judges writing letters to children could become the norm

    Matt Foster

    Quick Reads

  • The World’s Most Exclusive Gold Card

    Kurt Rademacher

    Quick Reads

  • What do the proposed changes to business property relief mean for Investors and Entrepreneurs and their businesses?

    Mary Perham

    Insights

  • The Good, the Bad and the Ugly - the inheritance tax Consultation on agricultural and business property

    Sarah Wray

    Quick Reads

  • Pet Ownership and Family Breakdown: Transatlantic Treatment of Pets on Divorce

    Miranda Fisher

    Quick Reads

  • Bank of Mum and Dad PLC

    George Harrison

    Quick Reads

  • Mike Barrington writes for Wealth Briefing on sole company directors

    Mike Barrington

    In the Press

  • Miranda Fisher and Matt Foster write for eprivateclient on the consequences of cohabitation

    Miranda Fisher

    In the Press

  • Sarah Jane Boon and Julia Cox write for Tax Adviser on safeguarding family wealth and the role of pre- and post-nuptial agreements

    Sarah Jane Boon

    In the Press

  • Living Together in the 2020s: Why more Gen Z’s are Saying 'Yes' to Cohabitation Agreements

    Cara Fung

    Quick Reads

  • Private wealth in motion: The great exodus

    Yacine Diallo

    Insights

  • Sarah Rowley writes for Charities Management on what charities should keep an eye out for this year

    Sarah Rowley

    In the Press

  • Yacine Diallo and Pierre-Philip Leroux-Moga write for Agefi Luxembourg on the migration of high-net-worth individuals

    Yacine Diallo

    In the Press

  • LADbible quotes Sarah Jane Boon on the legal binding nature of marriages from Netflix’s 'Love is Blind'

    Sarah Jane Boon

    In the Press

Back to top